Three reasons why your 2018 tax season is painful — and how to get right for next year
Unhappy with your 2018 tax return? Now’s the time to correct course to avoid the same outcome next year.
Tax refunds, which were off to a slow start early in the season, are also approaching parity with last year’s figures. The average tax refund as of March 22 is $2,915, according to the IRS. That’s just $10 — or 0.3 percent — down from last year.
Refunds aside, accountants are still finding themselves the bearers of bad news to some filers who found themselves owing this spring.
“We’ve seen people who never owed and now they owe,” said Dan Herron, CPA and partner at Better Business Financial Services in San Luis Obispo, California.
“I don’t think anyone had an understanding of what the tax reform dynamic would entail,” he said.
Accountants identified a few areas of the new tax law that tripped up some of their clients:
Withholding: The Treasury Department and the IRS introduced new withholding tables last spring to reflect the new tax code.
Employers use these tables as a guideline, along with your Form W-4, to calculate the amount of income tax to withhold from your pay.
If you withhold less in taxes, you take home more money. But you may owe the IRS next year if you withhold too little.
Withhold too much, and your pay will go down. But you’ll probably get a refund next year.
The IRS warned taxpayers that they needed to revisit their withholding in 2018, especially due to lower tax rates, the elimination of personal exemptions and changes to itemized deductions.
“When the new tables rolled out, the withholdings went down across the board,” said Sharif Muhammad, CPA and certified financial planner at Unlimited Financial Services in Somerset, New Jersey. “People don’t pay attention to their paystubs.”
Unreimbursed employee expenses: This now-suspended tax break is part of a group of miscellaneous itemized deductions, which you were only able to claim to the extent they exceed 2 percent of your adjusted gross income.
The inability to deduct unreimbursed employee costs hit clients in a range of industries, from traveling salesmen to construction workers and pipefitters, CPAs said.
More from Personal Finance
How much more you need to save for retirement, based on age
One way to get guaranteed income while delaying Social Security
What the Wyden-proposed tax on unrealized gains means for you
“It’s not unusual to see a pipeliner with $30,000 to $40,000 in unreimbursed employee expenses,” said Jeffrey A. Porter, CPA at Porter & Associates in Huntington, West Virginia. “They travel in a three- to four-state area, and those guys are getting hit hard.”
$10,000 cap on state and local income tax deduction: Clients on the coasts, particularly in high-tax states such as New Jersey and California, aren’t able to deduct as much of their state and local tax burden.
The top three counties with the highest average property taxes were Westchester County, New York ($17,392); Rockland County, New York ($12,925); and Marin County, California ($12,242), according to ATTOM Data Solutions.
In all, nine counties have an average property tax bill exceeding $10,000, ATTOM found.
“The whole game of prepaying your real estate taxes and claiming a deduction doesn’t pay anymore,” said Herron.
Don’t just seethe about your 2018 taxes.
Here are four steps you can take to make next spring less painful:
Revisit your withholding: If you failed to withhold enough tax in 2018, you’re set to be in the same position for 2019 unless you do something about it.
Whether you’re a former itemizer, a W-2 employee with side-gig income or a household with dependents, it’s worth reviewing your tax withholding.
This also applies to retirees who get their income from many sources: Use Form W-4V to withhold from your Social Security check, and Form W-4P to withhold from your pension.
Find tax savings opportunities at work: Saving in your 401(k) and contributing to your health savings account give you two benefits: lower taxable income and a shot at retirement security.
Here’s another tax play at work: A dependent care flexible spending account allows you to put away up to $5,000 on a pretax basis to pay for care if you have kids under age 13.
Give intelligently: If the higher standard deduction kept you from itemizing this year, talk to your CPA about bunching your charitable contributions so you can hit the hurdle next year.
“Bunching” allows you to cram in two or more years’ of charitable giving into one year. This way, you itemize deductions every other year.
Strategize now: Visit your CPA and draw up a plan to make 2019 less painful. “If the outcome wasn’t better, can we do things differently?” asked Porter. “Clients are more interested in hearing that now.”
Subscribe to CNBC on YouTube.